| Author |
Message |
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
quote:
Originally posted by francis:
Just to clarify. I suck at drawing so not trying. So just wanna ask. Offiside is intended only for use of the ACTIVE player? meaning if the ball is pumped towards the right sided player whom is onsite but there happens to be a offside player on the left hand side whom is coming back but not interfering with play. Will the ref count it as offside then?
yes, offside is meant for active players only. and "active" here carries several meaning.
as for your example, most of the time, ref will play on since the offside player is far from interfering the play.
the more contentious and challenging scenario would be having two strikers on the right, with striker A being onside, but striker B being offside + walking back.
|
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
Ball and the line
The ball must wholly cross the line to be considered a goal or out of bound.
It is still in play if it touches the line.
|
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
Outside Interference
Recalled the sunderland victory against liverpool where the ball got deflected by a beachball? The goal shouldn't have been counted.
Ref should stopped the play due to outside interference, and conduct a drop ball.
However, what if the ball were deflected off the ref instead? Yes, it is a goal coz ref is part of the game.
|
|
Louis Song
Posts: 40 |
Just wondering cause i saw henry did this before. Henry saw a teammate clearly offside and he lob the ball over the defence towards the offside teammate. Then he started running for the ball. The defenders thought he was passing to his teammate and stood still. Is this considered offside? Sounds to me like a grey area because you can't know what was henry thinking when he lobbed the ball over the defence. Btw,the ref did not blow for offside and henry went on for a 1on 1 wit a goalkeeper but he missed i think. But its quite unfair to the defenders from what i feel.
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
quote:
Originally posted by Louis Song:
Just wondering cause i saw henry did this before. Henry saw a teammate clearly offside and he lob the ball over the defence towards the offside teammate. Then he started running for the ball. The defenders thought he was passing to his teammate and stood still. Is this considered offside? Sounds to me like a grey area because you can't know what was henry thinking when he lobbed the ball over the defence. Btw,the ref did not blow for offside and henry went on for a 1on 1 wit a goalkeeper but he missed i think. But its quite unfair to the defenders from what i feel.
ref generally avoid having to blow the whistle and let the game flow. they are taught to let the situation developed for a couple of seconds more before deciding.
in the henry instance, it is kinda tricky but ref is not wrong to let the game continues.
tho it sucks if u are on the defense side.
|
|
Louis Song
Posts: 40 |
lets say my team just earned a free kick. are we allowed to stand beside the opp's wall? are we allowed to touch them as in try to move them abit.
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
quote:
Originally posted by Louis Song:
lets say my team just earned a free kick. are we allowed to stand beside the opp's wall? are we allowed to touch them as in try to move them abit.
yes, attacking team stand anywhere they want, including standing beside to form a fake part of the wall.
and no, attacking team cannot disrupt the wall.
u can nudge the wall with your shoulder but they are not obliged to move.
|
|
Alan Oh
Posts: 229 |
Wow.. Thanks for all the useful tips.
|
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
Q. Can the opposition stands right in front of a player taking a throw-in?
A. As long as the opposition is at least 2m away.
|
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
Q. My team mate tried to clear the ball in a penalty area, with his boot almost taking my face out. Is that dangerous play? Is it an indirect free kick or penalty?
A. Nothing. You can only foul against you opposition. The ref can send you off if you cause bodily harm to your team mate and that's about it.
|
|
David Tan
Posts: 605 |
Which part of the arm onwards is being considered handball? Anywhere below the shoulder?
|
|
|
Ash
Posts: 152 |
If I'm not wrong its anywhere below the shoulder but the application iof the handball rule differs from referee to referee. Some will give you the benefit of the doubt (ball to hand) and some will punish even the slightest unintentional contact.
|
Ash
Posts: 152 |
Dunno if you saw the recent video about this goalkeeper who celebrated after saving a penalty kick only for the ball to spin and trickle into the goal. And the referee allowed it to stand.
Q: What if a similar situation happen but the ball hits the posts (or crossbar) first, then hits the keeper and then goes in. This is in penalty shootout scenario.
|
Renjie
Posts: 133 |
yes is a goal......cos its still in the play.....as what the video has shown the goal still stands cos the ball din not come to a stop
|
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
quote:
Originally posted by David Tan:
Which part of the arm onwards is being considered handball? Anywhere below the shoulder?
yup. the entire arm, the red region illustrated below:
|
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
quote:
Originally posted by Asy'ari:
Dunno if you saw the recent video about this goalkeeper who celebrated after saving a penalty kick only for the ball to spin and trickle into the goal. And the referee allowed it to stand.
Q: What if a similar situation happen but the ball hits the posts (or crossbar) first, then hits the keeper and then goes in. This is in penalty shootout scenario.
as long as it is done in one attempt (by the taker), it is considered a goal.
u can have the ball bounce off the upright, hit the keeper, then rebound it off the goal post again, before rolling past the goal line. it is still a goal.
but make sure there is no beach ball in sight..
|
|
Karnex Ko
Posts: 681 |
i Got a Qn.
1. what happen if the keeper was to use his body to handle back pass but he is lying on the ground and never use his hand but the ref blow for the whisle does this consider a fault or either a indirect free kick???
|
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
quote:
Originally posted by karnex:
i Got a Qn.
1. what happen if the keeper was to use his body to handle back pass but he is lying on the ground and never use his hand but the ref blow for the whisle does this consider a fault or either a indirect free kick???
the keywords here are:
1. ref blew the whistle
2. backpass
it is an indirect freekick. how exactly it happens doesnt matter.
|
|
Kent
Posts: 2389 |
Q. A defender is awarded with a direct free kick, and he chose to pass back to his keeper. However, his keeper missed the ball completely and went into the net. Is it an own goal?
A. No goal. You cannot score an own goal directly from a restart.
If the free kick was taken outside the penalty area, it is a corner kick.
If the free kick was taken inside the penalty area, the free kick is to be retaken.
|
|
Ash
Posts: 152 |
quote:
Originally posted by Kent:
Q. A defender is awarded with a direct free kick, and he chose to pass back to his keeper. However, his keeper missed the ball completely and went into the net. Is it an own goal?
A. No goal. You cannot score an own goal directly from a restart.
If the free kick was taken outside the penalty area, it is a corner kick.
If the free kick was taken inside the penalty area, the free kick is to be retaken.
Hmm .. honestly didnt know there is such a rule. Good one Kent.
|
