Forum > Suggestion & Feedbacks > A Friendly match with real offical ref
Page 1 , 2
Author Message


Renjie
Posts: 133

4-Oct-2011 11:19:49 PM
i have a suggest...since we have not much friendly game and we are playing each other with players acting as players, how about we organise a friendly match 11 a side with real offical ref
.
Maybe can be held at the beginning of the year to mark a start of a new year? like EPL where there is a charity shield to kick start the season or end of the year to round up the season.

one way is at least we can learn through a real ref on what kind of foul made or how a real ref controls a game.......

This just a suggest see if anyone agrees or think is good to have........comments are welcome!!!!

The Legend never dies


Jason Hee
Posts: 108

5-Oct-2011 12:50:31 AM


sounds good!!!

All good athletes make mistakes; the great ones learn to make that mistake only once. ~ Raul Lopez


David Tan
Posts: 605

5-Oct-2011 8:21:49 AM
Can be explored... Thou that match will see limited slots available.

It can be a "season opener" of sorts whereby the BB cup winner takes on the BB challenge winner. Each team just have to choose another 6 to 7 more players if all 10 players from their existing squads are available.



Kent
Posts: 2389

5-Oct-2011 4:08:55 PM
interesting..quite in line with what david had in mind for mid-year.
if we're keen to have it aligned to the charity shield concept, we can have participating players fork out a little more.
after deducting the expenses, the remaining can be donated to choice of charity by the winning team/captain.

Steady lar!


Alson
Posts: 306

5-Oct-2011 10:53:21 PM
Donate to charity...i LIKE this idea!!!



Kelvin Tan
Posts: 62

6-Oct-2011 12:42:30 AM
Yeah sure, can donate to the 'Kelvin Needs Money' foundation.



francis
Posts: 33

6-Oct-2011 10:43:07 AM
quote:


Originally posted by David Tan:
Can be explored... Thou that match will see limited slots available.

It can be a "season opener" of sorts whereby the BB cup winner takes on the BB challenge winner. Each team just have to choose another 6 to 7 more players if all 10 players from their existing squads are available.



 ...... lousy idea. Just get the 2 captain to choose 14 players each.



Toni Teo
Posts: 72

6-Oct-2011 12:08:26 PM
i like this idea ... actually was thinking of Man Utd Beatles vs Liverpool Beatles ...
would be great if we could organize it under the floodlights ...
should be refreshing experience for all of us ....
i dream dream dream ....

19 going 20 and still counting ... now is 21


Ting Fu
Posts: 867

6-Oct-2011 2:16:07 PM
Personally I don't think it a good idea for "man U vs liverpool"....

it will divide the Beatles up....coming from a Liverpool fan....





Nam Sing
Posts: 135

6-Oct-2011 4:19:11 PM
It is a good idea. I support this.



David Tan
Posts: 605

6-Oct-2011 5:39:19 PM

We should just create and recruit new positions for beatles players. Referee and linesmen.

Get people who are interested in being referee/linesmen and want more practise to join our weekly games...as officials...and we'll give them real match-officiating experience/training every week (They just need to pay us a small nominal fee for this service to hone their refereeing skills). Haha.





francis
Posts: 33

6-Oct-2011 7:29:54 PM
quote:


Originally posted by Ting Fu:
Personally I don't think it a good idea for "man U vs liverpool"....

it will divide the Beatles up....coming from a Liverpool fan....





I wonder though..have we actually ever done a headcount of how many liverpool and ManU fans we have in the club?



Karnex Ko
Posts: 681

6-Oct-2011 8:59:22 PM
quote:


Originally posted by Renjie:
i have a suggest...since we have not much friendly game and we are playing each other with players acting as players, how about we organise a friendly match 11 a side with real offical ref
.
Maybe can be held at the beginning of the year to mark a start of a new year? like EPL where there is a charity shield to kick start the season or end of the year to round up the season.

one way is at least we can learn through a real ref on what kind of foul made or how a real ref controls a game.......

This just a suggest see if anyone agrees or think is good to have........comments are welcome!!!!



i totally like RJ Idea

Manutd For Life


Kent
Posts: 2389

7-Oct-2011 1:03:37 AM
looks like our guys are quite keen in this idea.
let me consolidate some of points raised:

- BB internal friendly match with external ref
- BB internal friendly match with our own ref & linesman
- donate proceeds to charity, choice of winning team
- donate proceeds to kelvin need money fund
- BB cup winners vs BB cup challenge winners
- BB regulars vs regulars (seeded draw)
- BB East vs West (david's original idea)

some of the above points could be contradicting. so let's hear what you folks have in mind specifically.

for me, my preference would be BB regulars vs regulars with an external ref, with the proceeds going to charity from all of us in BB.

and I agree with TF. let's leave the BPL rivalry at old trafford & anfield.

Steady lar!


francis
Posts: 33

Edited on 7-Oct-2011 10:20:46 AM

We should do a winning 11 tournament. That way we can have all the liverpool vs ManU rivalry we want.





Ting Fu
Posts: 867

7-Oct-2011 11:13:32 AM
quote:


Originally posted by Kent:
looks like our guys are quite keen in this idea.
let me consolidate some of points raised:

- BB internal friendly match with external ref
- BB internal friendly match with our own ref & linesman
- donate proceeds to charity, choice of winning team
- donate proceeds to kelvin need money fund
- BB cup winners vs BB cup challenge winners
- BB regulars vs regulars (seeded draw)
- BB East vs West (david's original idea)

some of the above points could be contradicting. so let's hear what you folks have in mind specifically.

for me, my preference would be BB regulars vs regulars with an external ref, with the proceeds going to charity from all of us in BB.

and I agree with TF. let's leave the BPL rivalry at old trafford & anfield.



given my temperament, i know this kinda rivalry match is too much for me to take.... i know myself quite well enough =)





Ken Yap
Posts: 9

7-Oct-2011 5:35:27 PM
I discourage for playing Man united's fans  Vs Liverpool's fan too.

Once a reds. Always a reds


Toni Teo
Posts: 72

7-Oct-2011 6:15:32 PM
sorry for my suggestion of MU vs REDS .. not to divide beatles in anyway ...
But how about playing under the floodlights ... XD

19 going 20 and still counting ... now is 21


David Tan
Posts: 605

7-Oct-2011 7:24:04 PM
Or we just do an Old Bird versus New Bird challenge..... And we'll name it the.......

ANGRY BIRD CHALLENGE! Haha
Just kidding!

We can just keep it simple:

1) fix a date and open up a fixture for 32 pax (16 per team)
2) close the fixture 1 mth prior to match day or when all slots filled whichever cones 1st
3) Poll for 2 captains
4) fix a day or a systen to arrange player allocation/selection prior to match day
5) select team colours prior to match day
6) lastly, play the game

Dun need too complicated.



RenYong
Posts: 3

8-Oct-2011 8:16:27 PM
 I second that idea of ANGRY BIRD challenge.

Page 1 , 2

Forum > Suggestion & Feedbacks > A Friendly match with real offical ref

Copyright ?2005 Ninpeh. All rights Reserved